The newest cyber threat that is challenging corporate America are invoice scams and invoice manipulation. Companies of all sizes are being targeted by cyber “bad actors”, commonly known as hackers and cyber thieves. Invoice scams & manipulations are happening at an alarming rate and many of the claims are not being covered because most insurance policies don’t have a coverage trigger that applies to this type of claim.
So What is Invoice Manipulation and Why is Important?
Invoice manipulation is the flip side of social engineering scams. In a social engineering scam, the insured’s company, or more specifically, an employee of the company, is tricked via a hack or phishing scam to voluntarily part with money, products, services or goods. Invoice manipulation is more devious in nature. It happens when the customers or vendors of an insured are tricked by a Bad Actor using legitimate email and data of the insured to get the customer or vendor to alter a payment or deliver of products, services or goods to the wrong location that is controlled by the Bad Actor.
Generally, the way this happens is a Bad Actor either gains access to one of your employee’s emails by a successful phishing scam or by breaching their personal accounts and securing a password they use at work. The scariest part of invoice scams is that they take time. The scammer sits and waits, watching your system, learning your habits, seeing all of that employee’s correspondence, and specifically learning how your company and its customer or vendors work together.
Then they wait until the right time to ask your customer or vendor to change a payment via wire to a new bank, or have standing deliveries redirected to a new worksite using the compromised account and then deleting the request and correspondence before your employee sees it.
The terrifying repercussion is that the insured has no idea the events have transpired until they go to either follow up for payment or secure more supplies, at which point they learn their money or order is gone and there is nothing they can do.
Misconceptions About Invoice Manipulation
The unfortunate misconception is that many companies think this type of incident is already covered in their policy. Many people believe since it starts with a phishing or a hack attack that their policies will have coverage under the social engineering clause. Again, since the social engineering clause is only designed to cover an instance when their own employee is being socially engineered or manipulated to give up money, products, services or goods, there is no coverage.
Invoice manipulation is not about your employee giving up money, products, services or goods. It’s about someone portraying themselves as your employee and convincing your customers and/or vendors to redirect payment, products, services or goods. This action, while similar in nature, is not the same. The crime is perpetrated on another party outside of your firm. So, it should be their problem right?
It doesn’t quite work that way, because the customer or vendor has an email or communication that legitimately came from your company and is related to actual payment, products, services or goods intended to be from you. The truth is, if your server sends the request, your customer or vendor is not responsible for your loss. While this seems unfair, the reality is that the courts and the insurers have defined the distinction between the two coverages.
Insured companies (the victims) often believe they have not done anything wrong so the transaction is void and should not be counted against them. Their logic is often that it is the customer’s or vendor’s social engineering issue and not their problem. Unfortunately, upon forensic review, the insured often finds they were hacked or phished.
Learning that cyber social engineering does not cover the loss, many try to look to other coverages. The next possible path would be crime coverage. Unfortunately, unendorsed crime policies are only designed to cover crime committed by your employees or theft at the business location so neither of these coverage triggers apply.
Since neither the unendorsed cyber policy nor the crime policy are triggered by this action, the customer or vendor deems the matter closed and the problem truly becomes that of the insured who was actually infiltrated by a bad actor in the first place.
How Does One Get Coverage?
This brings us back to the needs of an insured who has either not been paid or does not have the goods/services they need to conduct their business. How do they get coverage? As we have reviewed, it is not a social engineering coverage issue. Invoice manipulation coverage is currently the clearest insurance clause that can respond to these types of claims.
There are specific terms and conditions surrounding invoice manipulation claims. All cyber policies are non-standard so there is no one magic definition. Since this is a non-standard coverage that must be linked back to key definitions within the cyber policy, each carrier’s endorsement will be uniquely different from the other.
As with all non-standard products, the buyer must be aware of what they are purchasing. Not all insurance companies are offering coverage. The insurers who do offer invoice manipulation coverage also have varying terms, conditions and limits which may apply. The safest way to make sure you are getting invoice manipulation coverage is to ask for it and review the terms, conditions and limits. As the coverage evolves, it will become more standard but right now the forms vary from one another.
The final analysis – cybercriminals are getting smarter and cyber insurers are working hard to keep up with the demand to protect consumers.
Dorothea P. Westin
Cornerstone Support partners with Capitol Special Risks to provide clients with the best options for cyber, E&O, and other insurance policies.